Why Your Current SEO Strategy is Failing

Fixing a Failing SEO Strategy: Top 10 Reasons and Solutions

You have been working on your website for months or years but still haven’t seen much improvement. Find out why your current SEO strategy is failing.

In today’s digital landscape, SEO is crucial for driving targeted organic traffic and conversions to your website. However, many businesses realize their current SEO strategies are no longer delivering results.

If your website ranks on page 2 or 3 of Google, sees stagnating or declining traffic, and has lackluster conversion rates, your SEO strategy likely needs overhaul.

A flawed or incomplete SEO approach leads to poor search engine visibility, missing qualified visitors, and limited business growth. To turn this around, you must pinpoint and fix the gaps in your current strategy.

This comprehensive guide examines the top 10 reasons your current SEO strategy is failing, along with actionable tips to get your SEO back on track for success. Let’s diagnose the issues holding your rankings back.

Why Your SEO Strategy is Failing and How to Fix It

Your site lacks authorityLow domain authority, few/poor backlinksBuild high-quality backlinks, create authoritative content
Pages have thin contentLack detail and depth, low word countAdd more informative content, aim for 2,000+ words per page
Slow site speedLarge images, unoptimized code, inefficient hostingCompress images, minify code, upgrade hosting plan
Poor technical SEOIssues like broken links, duplicate contentAudit and fix technical problems, improve site architecture
Weak keywordsTargeting competitive, low-volume termsResearch new long-tail, low-competition keywords
Low-quality contentContent created just for keywordsFocus on valuable, engaging content that also optimizes for keywords
Not enough promotionLow/no social shares, lack of linksPromote content on social media, build links, increase brand awareness

Reason 1: You Are Not Doing Proper Keyword Research

Thorough keyword research provides the foundation for an effective SEO strategy. Targeting high-potential keywords that align with your business helps attract qualified organic traffic.

Without researching relevant keywords for your niche, industry, and audience, you may target overly broad, competitive terms or waste time optimizing for keywords that lack commercial value.

Neglecting keyword research or taking shortcuts leads to lackluster search visibility.

Action Tips for Proper Keyword Research

  • Leverage keyword research tools – Use Google Keyword Planner, SEMrush, Ahrefs, or Moz Keyword Explorer to generate keyword ideas and analyze monthly search volume, competition levels, and commercial intent.
  • Identify long-tail variations – Optimize for longer, more specific long-tail keywords, like “private dog training Austin.” Avoid short, highly competitive terms like “dog training.”
  • Align keywords to products or services – Identify your core products, services and content pillars. Find relevant keywords that you can realistically target.
  • Analyze your competitors – See which terms they rank for to find keyword opportunities. Use tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs to research competitors.
  • Use negative match keywords – Add negative keywords like “free” or “jobs” to target only commercial queries aligned with your offerings.

Taking time on the keyword research process directly impacts the quality of traffic you attract. Make this a priority.

Check Out: How to Build an Affiliate Marketing Business?

Reason 2: You Are Not Creating Content That Matches User Intent

Your website Isn’t Optimized for SEO

Your content must satisfy user intent and meet searcher needs. If your content does not answer users’ questions or solve their problems, they will quickly bounce back to the SERPs.

Failing to optimize your content for the types of queries and intent in your niche leaves visibility and conversions on the table.

Tips for Optimizing for User Intent

  • Informational queries – Create in-depth guides, tutorials, and how-tos optimized for keywords like “how to start a blog.”
  • Navigational queries – Have complete business info and contact options for queries like “pizza hut locations.”
  • Transactional queries – Include e-commerce elements like pricing, product filters, and Add to Cart for keywords like “buy yoga mats online.”
  • Commercial queries – Use convincing, optimized content to win the sale for searches like “the best mattress 2022.”
  • Tools to analyze intent – Search Console, Google Analytics, and Answer The Public provide insight into user behavior and queries.

Matching content format, length, and purpose to search intent leads to higher user satisfaction and lower bounce rates. Give users what they seek.

Check Out: How To Use Seo For Affiliate Marketing: A Complete Guide

Reason 3: You Are Not Following SEO Best Practices For Content

Why Your Current SEO Strategy is Failing?

Creating optimized, high-quality content is still crucial for SEO success. But failing to follow best practices results in content that does not attract search visibility or engagement.

SEO Content Creation Tips

  • Write for humans first, search engines second. Avoid awkward keyword stuffing.
  • Create pillar pages and long-form content organized around important topics.
  • Incorporate multimedia like images, infographics, and videos to engage visitors.
  • Check readability and improve flow with Hemingway App. Target grade 8 reading level.
  • Include semantic HTML elements like H2s, bulleted lists, and hyperlinked text.
  • Update and promote evergreen content regularly on social media. Refresh outdated posts.
  • Use Yoast SEO or another optimization tool to perfect on-page elements, meta data and readability.
  • Make content mobile-friendly and use responsive design across devices. Load speed matters.

Following SEO best practices improves content quality, relevance, and discoverability substantially.

Check Out: How Will Voice Search Impact Your SEO Strategy?

Reason 4: You Are Not Paying Attention to Technical SEO

Technical SEO optimizes site architecture, speed, mobile-readiness, and indexing issues. Ignoring technical SEO leads to a site that doesn’t function or load properly, delivering poor user experience.

Without good technical SEO, Google can struggle to crawl and index your site content, leading to declines in organic reach and traffic.

Tips for Improving Technical SEO

  • Check site speed – Use PageSpeed Insights and GT
  • Check site speed – Use PageSpeed Insights and GTmetrix to optimize page load times. Leverage caching plugins.
  • Improve mobile optimization – Make sure your site is mobile-friendly and pages load quickly on mobile. Use Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test.
  • Fix broken links – Identify and repair broken internal links, backlinks, and image/file URLs with Screaming Frog.
  • Enhance structured data – Add schema markup for FAQs, products, reviews, events, etc. Test with Google’s Structured Data Testing Tool.
  • Set proper redirects – Create 301 redirects for changed URLs and pages. Avoid broken redirects and chains.
  • Optimize site architecture – Use a simple IA and solid internal linking structure. Ensure metadata and URLs are SEO-friendly.
  • Check indexing – Confirm Google can properly crawl your site with the Index Coverage Report. Resolve issues.

Taking time to audit and improve technical SEO provides huge gains for organic visibility and traffic.

Reason 5 You Are Not Building Backlinks

Backlinks remain a crucial signal of credibility and authority in Google’s eyes. But not having an active link-building strategy severely limits your search visibility.

Without continuously earning quality backlinks from trusted external sites, your ability to rank for competitive keywords will plateau or decline.

  • Improve existing content – Make existing high-value content more share-worthy. Refresh and promote it.
  • Create visual assets – Develop link-worthy visuals like infographics, charts, and photos others can embed.
  • Publish guest posts – Write optimized articles for niche authority sites that accept contributor submissions.
  • Pitch roundup inclusion – Reach out to sites that compile “best of” articles in your industry.
  • Get local citations – Build links from directories like Yelp to enhance local SEO.
  • Fix broken backlinks – Find broken backlinks using Ahrefs and replace them with your high-value content.

Diversifying your backlink strategy helps build referring domains and earn authoritative links.

Check Out: How to setup the basic SEO technical foundations for your blog

Reason 6: You Are Not Optimizing for Local SEO

Google My Business impacts your local SEO

If your business depends on foot traffic or local brand awareness, optimizing for local SEO is critical. Neglecting local SEO misses potential nearby customers searching for your business.

Tips for Boosting Local SEO

  • Complete your GMB profile – Flesh out your Google My Business listing with photos, services, products, business info, and more.
  • Earn reviews and reputation – Get customer reviews on GMB, Yelp, and other directories. Be responsive and manage your reputation.
  • List business on directories – Claim and optimize citations on 50+ relevant local directories. Moz Local is a good tool.
  • Target local keywords and intents – Optimize for keywords that include your city, neighborhood, “near me” queries, and more.
  • Enhance on-site signals – Prominently display your address, phone number, and business info on your website.
  • Sponsor local events – Support neighborhood events, teams, and associations to build community awareness.

Optimizing your local SEO presence helps drive foot traffic, phone calls, and conversions from nearby customers.

Reason 7: You Are Not Leveraging Social Media

Reason 7: You Are Not Leveraging Social Media

Social platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest offer powerful opportunities to amplify your content and improve SEO.

But failing to connect your social media efforts with your SEO limits visibility. Content promoted solely on social media misses out on search traffic.

Tips for Integrating Social Media with SEO

  • Share new blog posts on social – Post your latest content across your social profiles to boost reach.
  • Participate in relevant communities – Join social media groups related to your industry. Provide value by answering questions.
  • Use hashtags strategically – Research and use trending hashtags related to your niche to tap into conversations.
  • Reward social shares – Run contests that encourage social sharing of your content for increased visibility.
  • Re-promote top-performing content – Repurpose evergreen social posts that drove high engagement in the past.
  • Link prominently to social profiles – Include social follow/share icons visibly on blog posts, site headers/footers, emails, etc.

An integrated social media and SEO strategy expands your reach exponentially across channels.

Check Out: SEO Writing: A Complete Guide to SEO Writing

Reason 8: You Are Not Using Analytics to Measure SEO

Consistent analytics review provides the visibility needed to evaluate SEO efforts and pinpoint issues limiting organic growth. Lacking proper reporting makes data-driven optimization impossible.

Use SEO Analytics for Insights

  • Traffic metrics – Track monthly users, sessions, page views, pages/session, and bounce rate. Look for changes over time.
  • Landing pages – See top pages attracting traffic. Identify issues with exits or bounce rates.
  • Rank tracking – Monitor rankings for target keywords in Google and Bing using rank tracker tools.
  • Backlinks – Check Ahrefs, Moz, or Majestic regularly. Analyze backlink velocity and quality.
  • Site audits – Use SEO tools like Screaming Frog for technical and performance insights.
  • ROI tracking – Connect SEO efforts to leads and conversions using Google Analytics goals and E-commerce tracking.

Consistent analytics review provides the roadmap to improve your SEO results. Leverage the data.

SEO evolves rapidly. From Google algorithm updates to new techniques and trends, failing to adapt can cause your rankings to decline.

Tips to Keep Your SEO Strategy Current

  • Read SEO news sites – Follow blogs like Moz, Search Engine Journal and SEMrush to learn about the latest updates.
  • Follow experts on social – Stay in the know by following prominent SEO thought leaders on Twitter, LinkedIn, and Facebook.
  • Check Google algorithm trackers – Use tools like Mozcast to monitor Google updates and fluctuations.
  • Incorporate new metrics – Adapt your strategy and content to fit newer metrics like click-through rate, dwell time, video, etc.
  • Learn new skills – Take online courses, workshops, or certifications to build expertise in newer areas of SEO.
  • Attend conferences and events – Conferences like Pubcon and Mozcon connect you with the latest strategies.

Building a process to continually educate yourself is crucial for keeping your SEO strategy current, relevant and effective.

Reason 10: You Are Not Tapping into Expert Help

If you have limited time, staff, or SEO expertise internally, an agency or consultant can short-cut your path to SEO success. But refusing outside help keeps your strategy stagnant.

Consider Hiring an SEO Agency or Consultant

  • Save time – Agencies handle time-consuming SEO tasks like content and link building.
  • Gain objective insights – A consultant can perform an unbiased audit of current issues.
  • Access specialized skills – Technical audits, link building, and data analysis require dedicated expertise.
  • Work smarter – The right agency partners to amplify your in-house efforts.
  • Enjoy flexibility – Scale SEO support up and down as needed.

Vet agencies thoroughly on expertise, results, and customer service first. But the right SEO help accelerates growth.


How to choose a good topic?

Research keywords and trends to find a topic that fits your brand, solves problems, and interests readers.

How to create an outline?

Outline the sections of your post to organize information in a logical structure before writing.

How to optimize SEO elements?

Use target keywords in headers, meta descriptions, alt text; include backlinks, optimize page speed, formatting.

How to make content scannable?

Use short paragraphs, subheadings, bullet points, bold text, images, and graphics to make content easily scannable.

How to promote your post?

Share on social media, email subscribers, link internally, pitch to influencers to extend reach after publishing.


Is your SEO strategy stalled out? Pinpointing gaps through this SEO audit process gives you a blueprint for getting your strategy back on track.

By focusing on foundational elements like keyword research, technical site health, optimized content, and backlinks, you can rebuild sustainable search visibility. Monitor analytics regularly, stay adaptable, and don’t hesitate to tap into expert guidance.

Now that you know why your SEO is underperforming, you can diagnose issues and forge an effective path forward. Are you ready to invest in the search visibility your business deserves?


1. 12 Reasons Your SEO Strategy Is Failing – Single Grain

Plenty of campaigns fail because the high rankings their managers sought come from keywords that simply aren’t searched for by regular users. It …

2. 5 Reasons Your Current SEO Strategy is Failing – DigitalMarketer

#1: You’re Not Using Content Clusters · #2: You’re Not Investing in Your Content · #3: You’re Using a Generalized CTA · #4: You Can’t See the …

3. 10 reasons why your SEO strategy fails – Startups Magazine

10 reasons why your SEO strategy fails · 1. Unrealistic keywords · 2. Too many keywords · 3. Slow site speed · 4. Mobile unfriendly pages · 5. Low-quality content · 6 …

4. 12 Reasons Why Your SEO is Failing in 2022 – Magnes Marketing

In this blog post, we’ll cover the top reasons for your SEO efforts to fail. If you’re not sure what is wrong with your SEO strategies, keep reading.

5. 3 Reasons Your Current SEO Strategy is Failing – Adapting Social

3 Reasons Your Current SEO Strategy is Failing · #1: You’re Not Using Content Clusters. Think about search engines like a highway, when driving, you have a …

6. Why Your SEO Campaign is Failing – Search Engine Journal

1. Your website is outdated · 2. You Haven’t Nailed On-Page SEO · 3. You’re Not Building Links Properly · 4. Your Content is Not Performing · 5.

Similar Posts